American Idol 2011; 13 perform

Well there were some ups and downs tonight. But all was good.

My Rankings

1. James - Showed a sensitive side
   
2. Scotty - Consistently good
   
3. Casey - Knows how to play to the Crowd; and they love him.
   
4. Pia
5. Lauren
6. Ashthon
7. Haley
8. Jacob - had some cracks tonight.
   
9. Stefano - Was that West Side Story?
10. Thia - a little sleepy.
    
11. Karen - got overwhelmed
    
12. Paul - not strong; but unique
    
13. Naima - dancing and singing. don't forget to breathe

So Here's my guess: Karen or Naima is going home tonight. They were the two weakest performances. I think Paul doesn't have a strong voice; I didn't see it, but the judges said they liked it.

I think Paul was the pick that the Judges would not have done. He wasn't the best performance and he hasn't excelled (in my opinon). we'll see tonight.